Productive Struggle

There is a phenomenon referred to in the education world as ‘productive struggle.’ Google’s AI Overview tells us that productive struggle is “a learning process that involves working through challenging problems to develop skills like perseverance, flexibility, and confidence. It’s often described as ‘the sweet spot of learning’ because it’s when students are engaged and challenged, but not overwhelmed.'”

I was remembering a week back to my days as an instructional coach when I went into some classrooms, asked the teachers to give a Math problem to their students, and then set a timer for 5 minutes. During that 5 minutes, groups of students could work together, but the teachers were asked to do something that is very contrary to the nature of a teacher – they were to remain silent and not offer assistance. In some classrooms, it was extremely challenging for the teachers to watch their students struggle. For some teachers, it was five minutes that seemed like eternity. Why? Because they wanted so badly to step in, to offer guidance, to help adjust incorrect thinking, to take their students off the hook.

What did we learn as a result of this practice?

  1. Sometimes we are too quick to step in. Struggle isn’t easy to watch. It can be painful to watch someone taking a wrong path or thinking through something incorrectly. The temptation is to jump in and rescue them instead of letting them learn from mistakes.
  2. We often sell others short. We make an assumption that they won’t be able to solve the problem and feel the need to intervene.
  3. It’s okay to allow the struggle to happen. The outcomes of perseverance, flexibility, and confidence are worth it.

As I was remembering all of this, I also thought about the spiritual application. You see, there’s really nothing new under the sun. Productive struggle isn’t a new concept. God has been using that strategy from the beginning of time.

Have you been there? God is the very best teacher, and He often puts us in situations where we experience productive struggle. He hasn’t left us, and He is there to intervene when needed, but He will let our faith be tested by problems, hardships, and trials.

When we are in those situations, we must remember that our struggle isn’t because God doesn’t care about us. We need to look for the ways that He is using the struggle to sanctify us, to develop us, to help us grow. It is because He cares for us that He lets us walk through seasons of productive struggle.

The Apostle Paul says it like this,

“Therefore, having been justified by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom also we have obtained our introduction by faith into this grace in which we stand; and we exult in hope of the glory of God. And not only this, but we also exult in our tribulations, knowing that tribulation brings about perseverance; and perseverance, proven character; and proven character, hope; and hope does not disappoint, because the love of God has been poured out within our hearts through the Holy Spirit who was given to us.” (Romans 5:1-5)

The outcomes of the productive struggle in our walk with Christ are perseverance, proven character, and hope. We grow in these through tribulations (afflictions, troubles, pressures).

Remember, the goal of productive struggle isn’t to completely overwhelm or destroy a person. Sometimes, we may feel overwhelmed, but again, God is the perfect teacher. He knows just how much struggle is needed to produce the desired outcome.

“No temptation has overtaken you but such as is common to man; and God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation will provide the way of escape also, so that you will be able to endure it.” (1 Corinthians 10:13)

God is at work within us, not for our comfort and ease, but for our good and His glory. It is a process to become more and more like Christ, and it isn’t easy or comfortable. But we can rest in the assurance that God is with us, even if He isn’t giving us the answers. Our willingness to grow through the struggles that we face provides the perspective we need to press on.

“Therefore we do not lose heart, but though our outer man is decaying, yet our inner man is being renewed day by day. For momentary, light affliction is producing for us an eternal weight of glory far beyond all comparison, while we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen; for the things which are seen are temporal, but the things which are not seen are eternal.” (2 Corinthians 4:17-18)

-Dana

Faithful Friends

Ah, the Christmas music at this time of year, right? Even now, while I’m sitting at my dining room table typing this, my youngest is watching a Disney holiday special, and the sounds of the season are taking over my living room. I love some good Christmas music!

One line in a classic Christmas song has been striking a chord (pardon the pun, couldn’t help it) with me this year. “Faithful friends who are dear to us gather near to us once more.” I think the reason it resonates for me right now is because I have been so blessed with faithful friends.

It’s been a hard season for my family, and life has taken some unexpected twists and turns. I probably don’t have to tell you that life is like that. Aside from my faith, it is my faithful friends who have been the source of much hope and encouragement.

Faithful friends who are dear to me gather near to me once more. Why once more? Because there will always be something. Some curveball, some adversity, some unexpected change. But in the wake of it all, there are my faithful friends. They pray for me, they cheer me on, they help me to keep my eyes on Jesus, they show up.

I’m so thankful that my family doesn’t walk through life alone. God has given us the gift of faithful friends. Honestly, I don’t always reciprocate the way I should. Today, I’m feeling the challenge to be the kind of faithful friend that has been modeled for me.

If you have been one of my faithful friends, please know how much I love and appreciate you. I probably don’t say it or show it enough. Your kindness and overwhelming support have helped to steady the ship in rough and uncharted waters.

I aspire to be a faithful friend. I have much to learn and much room to grow. I’m inspired by the examples I have in my own life, but also by Jesus, who is a perfectly faithful friend.

May this Christmas season find you and your family with faithful friends who are dear to you gathered near to you once more, and may you know the fellowship of Jesus, the most faithful of friends.

Dana

Give Me a Crayon!

Hi, friends. It’s been a while, hasn’t it? In case you don’t know me well, I can tell you that the past few years have been the busiest of my life. As a result, there hasn’t been much time or margin for blogging. I can’t commit to any kind of frequency here, but since I have a thought or two to share, I thought I’d go for it.

Part of my busy is a 9-year old autistic daughter. She is a gift, and I have learned so much from parenting her – much about her, much about others, and much about myself. Amelia is primarily nonverbal and is also a visual thinker. She thrives on routine, structure, and visual supports – all things which do not come naturally to me, ironically.

One thing I have learned to do is to create visual schedules for Amelia, especially when there is a change in routine or an undesirable event on the horizon. If you’re anything like me pre-Amelia, you’re probably asking, “What is a visual schedule?” It’s a pictorial representation of the steps to a routine or the events within a time period. When I make them, I put the picture on the left and a blank box on the right. As things occur, we check them off on the right. Visual schedules reduce her anxiety by offering predictability and structure.

Creating visual schedules is time consuming, so there are times I don’t do it. That happened this week. Even though I knew she would be out of school, off her routine, and surrounded by holiday kinds of crazy, I failed to be proactive. On Wednesday (the first day of Thanksgiving break for her), we all paid the price. There were a lot of tantrums and meltdowns involving screaming and head-hitting. We had a miserable day, and I headed into Thanksgiving knowing that there had better be a visual schedule for each day the rest of the week.

Thursday morning, I made her schedule and hung it on the refrigerator. She must’ve looked at it at least twenty times, and you could almost see the relief she felt in knowing what was coming. We got through both Thursday and Friday beautifully with the visual support.

Fast forward to this morning. Today’s visual schedule is complete and on the refrigerator with a trip to the trampoline park toward the end of the day. When she saw that trampoline picture, there was a surge of excitement and then the word, “Jump!” What a win, right?

What happened next is why I’m writing. She came up to me and said, “Crayons, crayons.” I thought, “Oh, how sweet. She wants to draw or color.” She generally hates all things fine motor, so I was feeling pretty happy. I handed her the pack of colored pencils and was about to get some drawing paper out. If you can guess what happened next, you’re one step ahead of where I was. 🙂 It took me a minute. You see, she had no intention of drawing or coloring. She grabbed the red colored pencil and raced over to the visual schedule. Yes, you guessed it. She was about to check off every box leading up to the trampoline park.

That’s what happens when visual schedules can only go so far. It’s what happens when she isn’t happy living in the present moment, but wants to rush ahead to the best part of the day. And this is when I started pondering and reflecting on my own heart.

Oh, how I wish God would give me a visual schedule. I would love to know exactly what’s coming – not just today, but maybe for the next month, the next year, the next five years. Wouldn’t it be so nice if things were laid out in such a way that I knew what to expect? How often is my peace tied to predictability and structure? How much do I wish that all the things that are in front of me were within my control?

This is where I had the ‘aha’ moment of the day. If God in His sovereign wisdom were to lay out a visual schedule for me, I would want to do exactly what Amelia did. I would want to say, “Give me a crayon! I’m checking off all the undesirable things and fixating on the things that will bring me the most happiness.” If I had a crayon, I would refuse to live in the moment. If I had a crayon, I wouldn’t learn to be content with what I have right now. If I had a crayon, I wouldn’t understand that true joy isn’t dependent on a certain event but on the assurance that all the events on my schedule are held in the most trustworthy hands imaginable.

Peace comes when I stop trying to get the crayon and choose to embrace what’s happening in the present as God’s perfect plan for me right now. I can face the unpredictability of life knowing that while I control absolutely nothing, God is in complete control of everything.

If you love someone with autism, please know that I am not minimizing or criticizing their actual need for structure and routine. That is a real thing. I am far from an autism expert, but I know the realities of neurodiversity as it relates to my own household. The supports are not just beneficial, they are absolutely necessary.

My prayer for myself and for my neurotypical friends today is that we will learn to find contentment in the right now because we know Who holds the future. There will be great things ahead of us, and there will be hard things ahead of us. God gives us grace for each moment. We don’t have to borrow grace for the next thing on our schedule because He will give it when we get there. We can trust Him. He has the schedule and the crayon, and He doesn’t make mistakes. I love this promise –

“You will keep the mind that is dependent on You in perfect peace, for it is trusting in You. Trust in the LORD forever, because the LORD, the LORD Himself, is an everlasting rock!” (Isaiah 26:3-4)

Dana

Diced Celery

Chop, chop, chop.  I heard the sound in the next room, a rhythmic reminder that I was not alone in the cabin.  It was quiet now, though, compared to the recent hustle and bustle of people bundling up and putting on their gear to head out into the frigid Michigan morning for some back-country snowmobiling.  I was in the bedroom, making use of the peaceful moments to spend time with God and let my heart and my brain recharge.  Vacations at our cabin in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula were wonderful and fun, but the family energy in such proximity could be over-stimulating.  Don’t get me wrong – I was incredibly thankful that we were there together – my mother-in-law and father-in-law; my sister-in-law, brother-in-law, niece and nephew; and my husband and 3 sons.  In fact, thankful was the appropriate attitude – we were preparing to celebrate Thanksgiving the very next day.

Chop, chop… the cutting slowed a bit, then stopped.  I hopped off my bed and went out toward the dining room/kitchen to see what was up.  My mother-in-law, Mary, sat at the long table that was made from a huge tree.  She had a cutting board in front of her and was dicing celery. 

Let me tell you about my mother-in-law.  Think of the kindest person you have ever known, then go a little kinder.  This lady had an amazing gift of encouraging others and letting them know that they mattered.  She had made “keep a positive attitude” her mantra for the last 5 years, as she battled first one cancer and then a second.  Mary loved holidays, and she loved cooking for her family, especially when using recipes that had been passed down from her mother or grandmother.  She was prepping the celery for one such dish, her classic stuffing, a standard at family feasts.  She had carefully planned the whole menu for this Thanksgiving dinner away from home, purchasing and packing the needed ingredients to make the dishes that defined the holiday for our family.  

As I started over to offer my assistance, she set her knife down, slowly stood up from the table and headed to her bedroom.   Looking at the stalks of celery yet to be diced and at the form lying in “grandma and grandpa’s bed,” grief washed over me.  Not fair!  All she wanted was to make the Thanksgiving meal like she had for so many years, and she didn’t even have the energy to cut the celery.  Should I go to her?  I didn’t want to intrude, but I followed my heart and entered her room, kneeling beside the bed where she lay. 

I put my hand on her shoulder, “Oh, Mary.” 

She smiled at me, and her eyes showed that she was thinking more about me than she was about herself.

“I can take care of the celery.  It’s no problem,” I said.  “Please, don’t worry about getting food ready – save your strength for spending time with the family.  Rest now and play euchre with your kids and grandkids tonight.”

I don’t even remember what she replied, but I know that I never sensed self-pity or anger.  I knew she was disappointed that her body couldn’t do the things she wanted it to do – the things she had always done.  But she rested.  I chopped the celery, and that evening she was up playing euchre, laughing with her family.

Thanksgiving was to be the last holiday we celebrated together.  She grew weaker, and her cancer started getting the upper hand.  Hearts breaking, we made her comfortable and took care of her.   On December 20, 2016, she breathed her last breath on this earth.  As our family spent time together that first Christmas without her, we remembered with gratitude the moments and the memories we had shared at Thanksgiving, less than a month earlier. 

More Thanksgivings have come and gone, more celery has been diced and more stuffing made.  Mary left us good recipes to follow.  As I remember and reflect, I realize she also left life lessons to follow.

Let people help you.  Yes, Mary let me help with the celery and the Thanksgiving preparations, and she had been letting me help since the first time I visited her home.  At other places when I was a guest, my offers to assist with clearing the table and cleaning the dishes had been dismissed.  “Go sit down!  It will just take me a minute.”  Not Mary.  She allowed me to work beside her, which made me feel useful, more like a family member than a guest.  Those times together in the kitchen gave us moments to deepen our connection.  I am prone to wanting to handle things myself, but I am learning.  Admitting I need help and letting others lend a hand, although humbling, lets them know they are needed, while also allowing me to accomplish more than I could on my own.  Working together builds relationships.

Euchre trumps celery.  When you must choose between having things just the way you want them (or the way they have always been) and connecting with your family, choose family every time.  Every one of us has limited capacity.  We need to be willing to surrender our desires for perfection, be flexible, and prioritize relationships.  As my pastor says, “people before projects.” 

Keep a positive attitude.  At times life is painful and difficult and seemingly unfair.  Focus on what is good.  Say it out loud to remind yourself if need be – I would guess I heard Mary say, “Keep a positive attitude,” hundreds of times.  There are always reasons for gratitude and things you can celebrate, but sometimes you must dig to find them.  It is worth the effort.  Remember, people are watching, and you are leaving a legacy. 

There are many more lessons my mother-in-law lived, but if I can learn these three, I will count that as success.  And I will remember Mary every time I chop celery. 

Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!

-Leah

God is Working

If anyone has a mantra, Barb does.  Ask her how she is, and every time she pauses, looks upward, and says, “God is working.”  I bet I’ve heard her say it more than a hundred times over the few months I’ve been driving her to church, and not just in response to the how-are-you-today greetings given by fellow worshippers.  She has said it about health problems and complicated relationships and heart-wrenching pain.  She says it with sincerity, reminding others (and sometimes reminding herself) that it is true.  God is working.

I park the van, open the doors and remove the tethers from her wheelchair.  I pull down the ramp, and Barb moves her right hand back and forth until she gets it on the joystick.  She turns the chair and goes down the ramp, heading toward the glass doors.  I hurry to replace the ramp and close the van, so I can be beside her as we make our way inside.  Spastic cerebral palsy has rendered Barb’s arms and legs twisted and minimally functional, but there is nothing slow about her mind.  As difficult as it is for her to make her voice and her body follow the instructions her brain is giving them, it seems effortless for her to smile and laugh.  She grins at the greeter who opens the door, saying, “Hi, Barb!  How are you today?” 

He looks puzzled when she answers – it’s difficult to understand her reply, and after a second, he nods his head, ready to give up and let her wheel by him.  But I stop.  I want him to know what she said.  I need to say it.  “She said, ‘God is working.’”  He smiles, and we move on into the church.

“God is working.”  I still struggle to understand how this woman who has faced so much loss and suffering, who depends on others for almost every task, who is so limited in her ability to speak understandably, and who is often mistaken as mentally handicapped, can repeatedly testify that God is working. 

Is God working?  Can we trust him to write our stories?  When we are frustrated and sad and things are decidedly NOT going the way we think they should, can we believe in the goodness and power of God? 

Barb says we can. 

Jesus said, “This is the work of God, that you believe in him whom he has sent.” (John 6:29)  Does that mean that God’s work allows us to believe or that believing is the work God gives us to do?  Or both? 

Jesus said, “My Father is still working, and I also am working.” (John 5:17).

God has a purpose, no matter what the circumstances.  Because he is good and he does good (Psalm 119:68), he will use all things for our good and for his glory (Romans 8:28).  In fact, what he is working on is us!  “For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in him.” (Ephesians 2:10 ESV).  God’s work is transforming us into masterpieces that can in turn do the good work that he has planned for us to do. 

Take heart, friend.  God is working.  Even when we can’t see it and don’t feel it, he is working.  We can trust him. 

Thank you, Barb, for reminding me!